Exodus 34:20

King James Version (1769)

20 But the firstling of an ass thou shalt redeem with a lamb: and if thou redeem him not, then shalt thou break his neck. All the firstborn of thy sons thou shalt redeem. And none shall appear before me empty.
Untruth

Common misinterpretations treat the neck-breaking of unredeemed donkeys as arbitrary cruelty rather than a practical measure to exclude unclean animals from sacred use, akin to other purity laws; others erroneously apply it literally to contemporary practice, overlooking its fulfillment in Christ's redemptive sacrifice that spares all believers; or disconnect it from the covenant renewal context after the golden calf incident, missing its typology of substitutionary atonement and the principle of generous giving in worship.

Truth

Exodus 34:20 instructs on the sacred obligations of firstborns under the Mosaic covenant, requiring the firstborn of donkeys—an unclean animal—to be redeemed with a lamb or have its neck broken to maintain ritual purity, while firstborn sons must be redeemed, symbolizing God's claim on all life spared during the Passover exodus; it culminates in the command that no one appear before God empty-handed, emphasizing worship with offerings of gratitude for divine deliverance and provision.

Read Exodus 34