I Chronicles 2:49

King James Version (1769)

49 She bare also Shaaph the father of Madmannah, Sheva the father of Machbenah, and the father of Gibea: and the daughter of Caleb was Achsah.
Untruth

Misinterpretations often dismiss the verse as irrelevant name-dropping, ignoring its vital role in tracing Judahite lineages for legal and historical purposes; others impose modern moral standards to criticize Caleb's concubinage without contextualizing it as a common ancient practice neutrally reported, not endorsed; some conflate this Caleb with unrelated figures or fabricate symbolic meanings like hidden prophecies in the names, diverging from the passage's straightforward genealogical intent.

Truth

This verse records part of the genealogy of Judah's descendants through Caleb, listing children born to his concubine Maachah—Shaaph, father of Madmannah; Sheva, father of Machbenah and Gibea—and identifying Achsah as Caleb's daughter, emphasizing the Chronicler's meticulous documentation of family lines to affirm Israelite heritage, tribal territories, and inheritance rights essential for the post-exilic community's identity and covenant continuity.

Read I Chronicles 2